Small Kitchen Appliance Safety: What to Check Before and After You Buy
How counter-top appliances fail according to the recall record, the everyday habits fire agencies recommend, what a testing laboratory mark means, and links to our kitchen recall and problem pages.
Research-based: public sources and consumer feedback, not hands-on testing. How we review
In this article
Air fryers, pressure cookers, toasters, kettles and blenders are the appliances most likely to be sitting on your counter, hot, while you are doing something else. When one does fail, the recall record shows it tends to be in one of a few ways, and a handful of habits and pre-purchase checks address most of them. This is the hub for our coverage of kitchen appliance recalls and problems: it sets out the general rules and links to the detailed pages.
Key takeaways
- Cooking is the leading cause of home fires in the US, and unattended cooking is the main factor
- Fire-safety agencies advise unplugging small appliances when not in use and plugging them straight into a wall outlet
- A certification mark from a recognized testing laboratory is worth checking for, and worth checking is real
- Recalls apply to specific models, so the model number matters more than the brand
- Melting, a burning smell, scorch marks or a tripping breaker are reasons to stop using an appliance at once
How big the risk is
The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) reports that kitchen and cooking equipment was involved in about 48 percent of home structure fires in the United States on average from 2020 to 2024, and that unattended equipment was a factor in a quarter of reported home cooking fires and half of the deaths from them. The US Fire Administration (USFA) likewise names cooking as the leading cause of residential fires.
Those figures cover all cooking, with ranges and ovens at the center. We did not find published fire statistics for air fryers, toaster ovens or other individual counter-top appliances, so we cannot tell you how any one type compares. What the recall record does show is the kind of fault that gets a small appliance recalled, which is the subject of the next section.
How Small Appliances Fail
These are the hazards named in the CPSC recall notices we have summarized elsewhere on this site. Follow the links for the models involved.
Overheating wiring and connections
The largest air fryer recall, of about two million units, was for a wire connection that can overheat. Overheating is the reason given in most of the air fryer notices we summarize, and it is not a fault you can see coming.
Source: Our summary of air fryer recalls
Lids that open under pressure
Several pressure cooker recalls involve a lid that can be opened, or comes off, while the pot is still pressurized, with burn injuries reported. One recall was for inner-pot markings that led people to overfill.
Parts that break when hot
Handles that melt or snap, a connector that fails between two baskets, and glass doors that shatter have all led to recalls. These are burn and laceration hazards more than fire hazards.
Source: Our summary of air fryer recalls
Batteries, in the cordless versions
Cordless kitchen tools contain lithium-ion batteries, and the warning signs are the same as for any other battery product: swelling, heat, smell and leaking. Our lithium battery safety guide covers charging and disposal.
Not every complaint is a safety matter. A worn coating, a smell from a new machine and uneven cooking are covered in air fryer problems beyond recalls.
Everyday habits that matter most
These come from the USFA and the NFPA.
- Unplug small appliances when you are not using them.
- Plug them directly into a wall outlet, not an extension cord or power strip.
- Use one heat-producing appliance per outlet at a time. A kettle and a toaster sharing an outlet is the situation the NFPA warns against.
- Stay in the kitchen while you are frying, grilling or broiling, and use a timer for anything slower.
- Keep appliances clean. Crumbs in a toaster and built-up grease can catch fire.
- Keep things that burn away from heat: oven gloves, towels, packaging, curtains.
- Replace an appliance with a cracked, damaged or loose cord. The USFA’s advice is to replace it, not repair the cord.
- Leave the clearance the manual asks for. Air fryers and toaster ovens vent hot air and need space behind and above them.
Warning signs: stop using it
- A burning or melting smell that is not food
- Scorch marks, discoloration or softened plastic on the body, the plug or the outlet
- A plug or cord that is hot to the touch
- Sparks, smoke, or a breaker that trips when the appliance is switched on
- A lid, latch or handle that no longer locks or sits properly
- A crack in a glass door or lid
Unplug it if you can do so safely, let it cool, and do not use it again until you have checked for a recall. This list is our own summary of the faults described in recall notices; it is not an official checklist.
Before you buy
- Search the model number for recalls. Our guide to checking whether a product has been recalled shows how. Do this for second-hand and clearance appliances above all.
- Look for a testing laboratory’s mark on the appliance itself. In the US, a nationally recognized testing laboratory is one recognized by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration to test products against safety standards. UL, ETL and CSA are the marks you will see most. The mark means that laboratory tested and certified the product.
- Be aware that marks are faked. UL publishes warnings about counterfeit UL marks, including on USB chargers, and notes that such products have not been evaluated at all. A mark that appears only in the listing photos, a misspelling on the label, or a seller you cannot identify are reasons for doubt. UL has an online directory for checking a certification.
- Check who is selling it. See how to judge an online listing.
- Read the critical reviews for safety words: smoke, melted, sparked, burning smell. Our guide to reading negative reviews explains how to tell a pattern from a single bad unit.
After you buy
- Register it, so the maker can reach you if it is recalled. See how to register a product for recall notices.
- Keep the manual and note the model and serial number.
- Know what the warranty covers, and what it does not. See what an appliance warranty covers.
- If it is recalled, follow the notice. How recall refunds work explains the remedies.
- If it seems dangerous and has not been recalled, report it. See how to report an unsafe product.
Our kitchen coverage
- Air fryer recalls: the models affected and how to check yours
- Air fryer problems beyond recalls: coatings, smell and uneven cooking
- Pressure cooker recalls and reported problems
- Is the Ninja Creami worth it?
- HexClad problems: what tests show and what the warranty covers
- HexClad vs Caraway
- Refrigerator problems: ice makers, compressors and what surveys show
How we researched this
The statistics and safety advice are from the National Fire Protection Association and the US Fire Administration. The description of testing laboratories comes from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s program pages and UL’s published counterfeit warnings. The failure modes are drawn from CPSC recall notices summarized in our own recall pages. We did not test any appliance, and the list of warning signs is our own.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I unplug small kitchen appliances when not in use?
Yes. The US Fire Administration advises unplugging small appliances when you are not using them, and plugging them directly into a wall outlet when you are.
Is it safe to plug an air fryer into an extension cord?
Fire-safety guidance is to plug small appliances straight into a wall outlet, and to run only one heat-producing appliance from a outlet at a time.
What does the UL or ETL mark mean?
It means a nationally recognized testing laboratory tested and certified the product against a safety standard. Check that the mark is on the appliance itself, because marks are sometimes counterfeited.
Are air fryers a fire risk?
We found no published fire statistics for air fryers specifically. Several models have been recalled for overheating, so check your model number and follow the manual’s instructions on clearance.
What should I do if an appliance smells of burning?
Unplug it if it is safe to do so, let it cool and stop using it. Check for a recall on the model, and report it to the CPSC if it seems dangerous.
Sources & Evidence
Where the facts in this article come from. Summaries are in our own words; follow the links to check them yourself.
More on: Home Appliances Product Safety & Recalls





