How to Judge an Online Listing Before You Buy
Seven quick checks, from who the seller really is to how you are asked to pay, that tell you most of what you need to know about an online listing before you order.
Research-based: public sources and consumer feedback, not hands-on testing. How we review
In this article
A product listing is an advertisement written by the person who profits from the sale. Most of what you need to judge it is on the page or one search away, if you know where to look and in what order. This guide sets out seven checks, each taking a minute or two, drawn from the Federal Trade Commission’s consumer guidance and the disclosure rules that now apply to online marketplaces. It also ties together our more detailed guides and the two free tools on this site.
Key takeaways
- Find out who the seller is: US marketplaces must show the name and contact details of high-volume sellers
- Read the critical reviews first, and treat the star average with caution
- Add up the real price, including shipping and other extras
- Check the return terms and the delivery promise before you pay
- Search for recalls on anything electrical, for children or bought second-hand
- Pay by credit card, and never by gift card, wire transfer or cryptocurrency
1. Who is actually selling this?
On a marketplace, the name at the top of the site is often not the seller. The FTC points out that some marketplace operators leave payments, returns, refunds and delivery entirely to the individual seller and buyer, so the seller’s identity decides how much help you will get if something goes wrong.
US law now helps you find out. Under the INFORM Consumers Act, which took effect in June 2023, an online marketplace must show shoppers the following for its larger third-party sellers, either on the product listing or in the order confirmation and your account history:
- the seller’s full name, which can be a business name;
- a physical address, though a seller working only from home may show just a country and state;
- a way to contact the seller directly.
The listing must also give you a clear way to report suspicious activity to the marketplace, by phone and electronically. The FTC’s first case under the Act, in September 2025, was against Temu; our guide on whether it is safe to buy from Temu has the details. We have looked at TikTok Shop, Shein and AliExpress in the same way.
What to do: find the seller’s name and location, then search for that name with the word “complaint”. If you cannot find who the seller is, do not buy.
2. What do the reviews really say?
The FTC’s advice is not to judge by star ratings alone, because some reviews and ratings are fake or misleading, and fake reviews can be negative as well as positive. The critical reviews usually tell you more than the average does.
- Our guide to reading negative reviews shows how to separate a real, recurring fault from noise.
- Our guide to spotting fake reviews lists the warning signs and what the law now says about them.
- The Fake Review Checker walks you through those signs for a specific listing.
3. Do the photos and description show the real thing?
The FTC notes that if a listing does not show pictures of the actual item, you cannot check its condition or even be sure the seller has it. Look for photographs from buyers, check that the specifications are stated in numbers and not adjectives, and be wary of a description that could apply to any product in the category.
4. What is the real price?
Comparison shopping is worth the minute it takes, but the FTC warns that the prices you compare may not include shipping and other add-ons. Go as far as the final checkout screen before deciding which offer is cheapest. A price far below every other seller’s is not proof of a problem, but it is a reason to do the other checks carefully.
5. What happens if it is late, or you want to send it back?
Two different things are easy to confuse here.
Delivery is covered by a federal rule. A seller must ship when its advertising says it will, or within 30 days of your order if it gives no date, and must offer you a refund if it cannot.
Returns are mostly up to the seller. Before you buy, the FTC suggests finding out who pays the return shipping, how many days you have, and whether there is a restocking fee. Sale and clearance items often have stricter terms. On a marketplace, check whether the platform’s guarantee applies and how short its claim window is.
Our guide to returns, refunds and chargebacks gives the full sequence, and how to get a refund from Amazon covers that marketplace’s process step by step. For apps, subscriptions and games, see how to get a refund from Apple and from Steam. We also cover refunds from DoorDash and Ticketmaster.
6. Has it been recalled, and is it the kind of product that could be?
A listing will not tell you that a product has been recalled, and a recalled item can still be offered for sale, particularly second-hand. For anything electrical, anything for a child and anything bought used, search the brand and model on the CPSC’s site before you pay. Our guide to checking whether a product has been recalled shows how in two minutes. If something you bought turns out to be dangerous, how to report an unsafe product explains who to tell.
7. How are you being asked to pay?
The FTC says a credit card gives you the strongest protection for an online purchase, because you can dispute a charge if you are billed twice, the goods never arrive, or they arrive wrong or defective. It treats a seller who insists on a gift card, wire transfer, payment app or cryptocurrency as a probable scam, since money sent that way is very hard to recover.
One common misunderstanding: a web address beginning with https means the connection is encrypted. It does not mean the site is honest. The FTC notes that scammers encrypt their sites too.
Two tools that do part of the work
- The Buyer Risk Checker asks what you can see on a listing, such as the spread of ratings, the price and the seller’s history, and gives a rough reading of the risk. It is a rule-of-thumb aid, not a verdict on any product.
- The Fake Review Checker is a checklist for the reviews on a single listing.
Keep a record as you buy
What to save
- A screenshot of the listing, including the price, the description and the seller's name
- The return policy and the promised delivery date as shown when you ordered
- The order confirmation
- Every message between you and the seller
- The card statement showing the charge
The FTC recommends keeping these for every online order. They are what a marketplace or card issuer will ask for if you need to make a claim.
How we researched this
This guide is based on the Federal Trade Commission’s consumer advice on online shopping and marketplaces and its guidance on the INFORM Consumers Act, with links to the official pages. It describes US rules as of October 2026 and is general information, not legal advice. The checks are our arrangement of that guidance into a sequence; the FTC does not publish them as a numbered list.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I tell if an online seller is legitimate?
Find the seller’s name and location on the listing, search for that name with the word complaint, read the critical reviews, and check the return policy. On US marketplaces, larger third-party sellers must have their name, address and contact details shown to shoppers.
Are star ratings reliable?
Not on their own. The FTC advises against judging by star ratings alone, because some ratings and reviews are fake or misleading. Read the written reviews, especially the critical ones.
What is the safest way to pay online?
The FTC says a credit card gives the best protection, because you can dispute the charge if something goes wrong. Be very wary of any seller who will only take a gift card, wire transfer, payment app or cryptocurrency.
Does https mean a shopping site is safe?
No. It means the connection is encrypted. The FTC notes that scam sites can be encrypted too.
How long does an online seller have to ship my order?
Under the FTC’s rule, by the date the seller promised, or within 30 days of your order if it gave no date. If it cannot, it must offer you a refund.
Sources & Evidence
Where the facts in this article come from. Summaries are in our own words; follow the links to check them yourself.
- FTC: Online Shopping
- FTC: Buying From an Online Marketplace
- FTC: What to know before you buy something online
- FTC: The INFORM Consumers Act and online marketplaces, what to know (2023)
- FTC: Informing Businesses about the INFORM Consumers Act
- FTC: How To Evaluate Online Reviews
- FTC: Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule
- FTC: Online Marketplace Temu to Pay $2 Million Penalty for Alleged INFORM Act Violations (September 2025)
- CPSC: Recalls and Product Safety Warnings
More on: Online Shopping





