TV Reliability: What Owner Surveys and a Long-Run Test Show
What Consumer Reports' owner survey and RTINGS' test of 100 TVs over 10,000 hours show about which televisions develop faults, what the manufacturers say in reply, and what to check before you buy.
Research-based: public sources and consumer feedback, not hands-on testing. How we review
In this article
Quick Verdict
Bottom line: No public source can tell you whether one set will fail. The evidence does tilt the odds: brands differ in owner surveys, and in a long-run lab test thin edge-lit LCD sets developed faults far more often than other designs.
- Main concern
- Thin edge-lit LCD sets run for long hours at high brightness, and OLED sets that show a static image all day
- Better alternative
- A direct-lit or full-array LCD set, if long life matters most to you
Research-based: public sources and consumer feedback, not hands-on testing. How we review
There is very little public information about how long televisions last. Manufacturers do not publish failure rates, and most reviews are written after a few weeks with a set. Two sources go further. Consumer Reports asks its members what went wrong with the TVs they bought, and the test lab RTINGS has been running one hundred TVs almost continuously since 2022 to see what breaks. They measure different things and should be read differently. This report sets out what each one shows, what the manufacturers say in reply, and what it means when you are choosing a set. We did not test any television.
Key takeaways
- Consumer Reports rates TV brands on predicted reliability by the fifth year of ownership, from a survey covering about 122,000 sets
- In its 2019 analysis it estimated that about one in five Hisense and Vizio sets would develop a problem within five years, against about one in nine for Sony; both companies disputed that
- RTINGS ran 100 TVs for over 10,000 hours and found thin edge-lit LCD sets developed faults far more often than other LCD designs
- All 18 OLED sets in that test showed burn-in, under deliberately extreme conditions
- Samsung and LG told RTINGS their own data shows no difference in real-world durability
What the owner survey shows
Consumer Reports’ reliability ratings come from its members. Its current TV pages draw on reports covering 121,881 new sets bought between 2015 and 2025. From those it estimates how likely a brand’s TVs are to have a problem by the end of the fifth year of ownership, and it also reports how satisfied owners are. A brand rated fair or poor for predicted reliability cannot be recommended by Consumer Reports, however well its sets do in the lab.
The current brand-by-brand ranking is published for Consumer Reports’ members, and we could not read it. What is public:
- The 2019 analysis. Based on 97,554 sets bought between 2010 and 2018, Consumer Reports estimated that 20 percent of Hisense and Vizio TVs would experience a problem within five years, and rated both brands fair. Its estimate for Sony, rated very good, was 11 percent. It withdrew its recommendation from Hisense and Vizio sets as a result, and said Element, RCA and Westinghouse also had below-par ratings.
- The companies’ replies. Both disputed the findings. Hisense said its defective rate was under 4 percent, and Vizio said it strongly disagreed with the rating.
- Owner satisfaction in the same survey was highest for LG, Samsung and Sony, with TCL just behind.
- A more recent indication. LG publishes on its own website a reprint of Consumer Reports’ brand reliability page that shows LG ranked first of 16 brands. That is a reprint chosen by the company it flatters, so treat it as an indication and check Consumer Reports’ current ratings.
The 2019 figures are seven years old. Do not read the old ranking as today’s.
What the long-run test shows
RTINGS began an accelerated longevity test on 100 TVs in October 2022. By July 2024 the sets had run for more than 10,000 hours, which it equates to roughly six years of use in a typical US household. The TVs run at maximum brightness and are switched on and off daily.
What Failed, and Why
From RTINGS' published findings after more than 10,000 hours. The percentages are shares of the sets in its test, not of TVs in general.
Thin edge-lit LCD sets
Seven of the eleven edge-lit sets in the test developed visible uniformity problems, and one failed outright. Among the 71 LCD sets with lights spread across the back of the panel, 14 had such problems. Three of the edge-lit sets showed deterioration by about 2,200 hours.
Source: RTINGS: Thin LCD TVs Break Faster Under Prolonged Use
The cause: heat in one place
An edge-lit TV packs its LEDs along the bottom edge. RTINGS took the failed sets apart and found warped reflector sheets in every one, along with cracked or partly melted light guide plates and burnt-out LEDs. It measured an LED surface temperature of 123 degrees Celsius on one set at full brightness.
Source: RTINGS: Thin LCD TVs Break Faster Under Prolonged Use
Not a matter of price
RTINGS says edge-lit sets are not cheap to make and that expensive ones share the same basic design. It found the same failure pattern in Samsung and LG models, which made up most of the edge-lit sets in its test, and attributes it to the design, not to a brand.
Source: RTINGS: Thin LCD TVs Break Faster Under Prolonged Use
OLED burn-in
All 18 OLED sets in the test showed burn-in. The test streams a news channel constantly, with its static logos and tickers, at maximum brightness, which is far harsher than mixed viewing. LCD sets do not suffer permanent burn-in.
Source: RTINGS: Longevity Burn-In Test
What the manufacturers say
RTINGS published replies from the companies. Samsung said edge-lit technology has been used reliably in its LCD products for more than fifteen years and shows durability comparable to direct-lit models in real-world conditions. LG said that while the types of failure may differ between designs, it has not seen any difference in the defect rate. Those statements are about ordinary home use; RTINGS’ test is deliberately not ordinary use. Both can be true.
How to read the two together
| Consumer Reports survey | RTINGS longevity test | |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Problems owners report in real homes | What breaks under continuous, maximum-brightness use |
| Level | Brand | Design and individual model |
| Sample | Very large | One hundred sets, a handful of each type |
| Main limit | Self-reported; brand averages hide differences between models | Accelerated; small numbers; harsher than home use |
Neither can tell you whether a particular TV will fail. A brand with a weak rating still sells many sets that never go wrong, and Consumer Reports says as much. What the two sources give you is a way to tilt the odds.
What to check before you buy
- How the screen is lit. If long life matters to you and you are buying an LCD set, RTINGS’ advice is to prefer a direct-lit or full-array model to an edge-lit one. Detailed reviews state the backlight type, and RTINGS notes that edge-lit sets are on average the thinnest LCD TVs it has tested.
- The brand’s current reliability rating, in a survey you can see the date of.
- How you will use it. RTINGS suggests that owners of edge-lit sets avoid prolonged use at maximum brightness. An OLED that will show the same static image for many hours a day is the case its burn-in results speak to.
- The warranty, and what it excludes. See what an appliance warranty covers, which also explains why the FTC advises caution about extended warranties.
- The seller and the return window. Our guide to judging an online listing covers the checks.
When This Evidence Should Weigh Heavily
- You keep a TV for many years
- The set will be on for most of the day, or shows the same channel for hours
- You are choosing between a thin edge-lit model and a thicker one at a similar price
When It Matters Less
- You replace your TV every few years
- The set is used for a few hours of mixed viewing a day
- You are buying mainly on picture quality and accept the risk
This split is our own reading of the two sources.
For the same question about computers, see laptop reliability.
How we researched this
This report is based on RTINGS’ published longevity research and test updates, which we read in full, and on Consumer Reports’ published articles about TV brand reliability, including its 2019 analysis. Consumer Reports’ current brand ranking is for members, and we read its pages as search excerpts, so we have reported only what its public articles state. We did not test or survey anything ourselves, and we name a brand only where one of these sources does.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which TV brand is the most reliable?
Consumer Reports’ current ranking is published for its members and we could not read it. In its public 2019 analysis Sony was rated very good and Hisense and Vizio fair, which both companies disputed. Check a current survey before relying on any ranking.
How long should a TV last?
No public source gives a firm figure. Consumer Reports measures problems by the fifth year of ownership, and RTINGS’ test simulates roughly six years of typical use. Both report specific faults, not an average lifespan.
Are edge-lit TVs less reliable?
In RTINGS’ accelerated test, seven of eleven edge-lit sets developed uniformity problems against 14 of 71 other LCD sets. Samsung and LG told RTINGS their own data shows no difference in real-world use.
Do OLED TVs still burn in?
All 18 OLED sets in RTINGS’ test showed burn-in, but that test streams a news channel constantly at maximum brightness. Mixed viewing is much less demanding.
Is an extended warranty on a TV worth it?
The FTC advises caution: a service contract may duplicate the manufacturer’s warranty and may cost more than the repairs it covers. Ask what it excludes before you buy one.
Sources & Evidence
Where the facts in this article come from. Summaries are in our own words; follow the links to check them yourself.
- RTINGS: Thin LCD TVs Break Faster Under Prolonged Use (updated July 2024)
- RTINGS: Longevity Burn-In Test, updates and results from 100 TVs
- Consumer Reports: Hisense and Vizio TVs Lose CR's Recommendation Over Reliability Issues (2019)
- Consumer Reports: Best TV Brands of 2026
- LG: reprint of Consumer Reports' TV brand reliability page (PDF)
- FTC: Extended Warranties and Service Contracts
More on: Electronics





